
This year was a fantastic year for tomatoes in my garden.
🤔It started out rough, with plants taking almost three weeks to take off after transplanting.
Then off they went,😄 and then we had a super-hot spell, and they pretty much stopped growing. Tomatoes don’t like it when it gets over 85°F and with weeks of 90+, they were kind of like me, not wanting to move.🙄
🌞The good thing about the hot spell was the afternoon rains which meant I didn’t have to water, and the plants were getting enough water to keep them alive to endure the heat.🌦️
Then, cooler weather! 🥳And the tomatoes took off with more fruit than I have had in five years. Now with the temperatures in the upper 70s to low 80s during the day, they are some happy plants and we had enough to do a proper tomato tasting.
This year I grew 32 varieties of tomatoes this year in four beds. One bed was for the cherries, one for the big slicers, one for the round red and pinks and one for the paste and processing varieties.
Here are the standouts and winners in each category.
The grand taste test winner is at the bottom along with the three epic failures.
Round Reds and Pink Tomato Taste Test Winners
In this category, we chose one favorite and one honorable mention.

The honorable mention is Porter.
This is a small round pink tomato that I grew for the first time in honor of my Dad, who’s name was Porter, and who taught me allot about gardening.
Porter is a mellow but good flavored tomato that would be well suited to a tomato salad. It has a reputation for liking it hot and dry, so it would be a good variety if you are in that type of climate, or for insurance against a drought year. Fruits tend to be about 3”.
I got the seeds from MI Gardener.

The round red taste winner is Old Virginia.
We have grown this one for a few years and it has a simply well rounded flavor that has that good old tomato tang. I know some people like the purely sweet tomatoes and don’t like the tang, but I like a bit of it and Old Virginia delivers. This is a good fresh eating tomato and would also be good in a tomato salad. Fruits tend to be about 3-4”.
Seeds were from Southern Exposure Seed Exchange.
🧂FYI – we always try the first taste of each with no salt, then with a bit of salt,
Roma and Processing Tomatoes Taste Test Winners
We have four that made it in this category this year.

Black Plum is roasting tomato winner.
For a roasting tomato, once again, we liked Black Plum. These are small (1″ x 2″) plum shaped tomatoes that are good fresh, but really shine when roasted with some olive oil, salt and herbs. This seems to bring out their flavor.
The seed I started was from Southern Exposure Seed Exchange.

Tomato winner for making salsa is Siletz.
For a round red processing tomato, we liked Siletz. I have been growing this one for years and still like it for making salsa. This is the only determinate variety on my list this year, and it continues to satisfy.
You can get Siletz seeds from Territorial Seed Exchange.
Then there are two roma types and they are very different in their flavor profile.

Cream Sausage a different flavor for sause.
A new one for me this year, recommended by a gardening friend who is a true Italian, is Cream Sausage.
People can be skeptical about a light yellow cream colored tomato, and they shouldn’t be. This is one of those surprises. The flavor is different from a red roma like San Marzano, but it is subtle and yet complex. It does taste like a tomato, but a different one. Then when we tried it with a bit of salt, wow did it pop! The use for tomato sauce became instantly clear. The sauce would taste different and oh, so good.
I got the seeds from my friend Jackie, but you can get it from Botanical Interests.

San Marzano the standard is still the winner.
Then there is good old San Marzano. There is a reason why this is the standard for roma types. They are meaty and perfect for making sauce. We enjoyed munching a couple fresh too.
I got this batch of seeds from Southern Exposure Seed Exchange.
Cherry Tomato Taste Test Winners
We have four in this category and honestly three of them are same ones that seem to win year after year, with a few exceptions. We do keep trying other varieties, but we keep coming back to these.

Orange Rossellini a new surprise.
For reds this year it was Orange Rossellini. I confess this was the last year I was going to grow this one, it was it’s last chance. I grow tomato varieties three years before I decide if they go into my regular varietal rotation or I give up on them. The last two years Orange Rossellini was meh and I didn’t have high hopes for it this year. It was not a strong producer, didn’t get allot of fruit from it, but oh boy were they delicious! Bright, yet sweet with a bit of tang. Well rounded flavor. It saved itself. I got seed from MI Gardener.

Esterina yellow cherry tomato taste test winner.
As is has been the case for several years now, Esterina is our hands-down favorite yellow cherry tomato. It is everything you want in a yellow cherry, sweet cherry tomato. They make the best snack and get eaten so fast they don’t make it to garnish a green salad. I am munching on these while I write this post.😋
I get the seeds from High Mowing Organic Seeds.

Moonbeam another great snaking cherry tomato.
Also in the yellow range is the Moonbeam, which is a very small roma shaped grape that I love to snack on also. It comes from High Mowing Organic Seeds.

It has interesting habit where when the fruit is ripe, it falls of the vine and you harvest it from the ground. This would be fun for kids.
The taste is mild, but not bland. It is meaty, not as juicy and I find myself happily munching them. My volunteers agree it is a fun snack.

Full bodied cherry tomato taste test winner is – Chocolate Cherry.
The last of the cherry types is my old favorite, Chocolate Cherry. (I am munching a few of them too). If you like sweet tasting heirloom slicers, then this is the cherry for you. It is a sweet cherry, but it has the rich flavor of a purple slicing tomato. What’s not to love?💜
Seeds are from Territorial Seed Company.
Big Slicing Tomato Taste Test Winners
We have four winners in this category including what I am calling our grand prize of the year.
Let’s start with the two purples.

Cherokee Carbon a cross between two heirlooms.
First is Cherokee Carbon, which is a cross between Cherokee Purple and Carbon. Cherokee Purple has been a traditional favorite, but a low yielding variety. The Cherokee Carbon is as yummy, but produces better. The flavor is rich, complex and deep. There is a certain flavor profile to the purples that I like as it is the most well balanced in flavor. It is meaty with some juice and great to slice and eat fresh.
You can get seeds from High Mowing Organic Seeds.

Purple Calabash wins the tomato purple tomato tasting test.
Next comes Purple Calabash. I grew this several years ago and really loved it, but then it had a couple bad years and so I stopped. This is a “ruffled” variety which can tend to split and rot if is gets too much water – not this year. It is the highest producer of the slicers and as soon as we tasted it, we were – yes – yum – wow, this is why I wanted to grow it again. The stem end will sometimes stay green a be a bit tough, but don’t let that put you off, it is a taste sensation.
As the season progresses, the fruits got smaller, but who cares then it is still producing yummy tomatoes.
Seeds were from Sow True Seed.

Pineapple for something different.
Want a tomato that hardly tastes like a tomato, but is still good? Then try Pineapple. I had kept passing this one up and not growing it, but decided to try it this year. It hardly tastes like a tomato, more like a sweet fruit that you can’t put your finger on where you have tasted anything like it before. We kept looking at each other confused, but kept going back for more because it was so cool, and different and tasty.
You can get seeds are from Tomato Fest.
Now for the Grand Tomato Taste Test Winner
Followed by the epic fails of the year.

Thorburn’s Terra Cotta is the grand tomato taste test winner. 🥳🎉😋
The Grand Tomato Taste Test Winner is Thorburn’s Terra Cotta. This is the tomato that is the star of the show. 🌟It is so full of flavor, so balanced, between sweet, and full bodies, with a touch of tang. It has so much flavor that is it shocking. This was last year’s winner too and if you grow slicers, try it. It may not be the prettiest tomato, but with flavor like this, who cares!
Seed were from Baker Creek.
Epic Tomato Variety Fails
When you grow over 30 varieties each year as I do, there are bound to be some that just don’t cut it. It could be they had a bad year, didn’t produce, died or just didn’t taste good.
I tend to give variety three years of trials because each year can be different.
This year we had four epic fails.
Pink Oxheart
The first is one that normally does fantastic for me and others. Pink Oxheart. For the last three years it has grown huge, produced and abundance of great tasting tomatoes. Not this year. It grew tall, then died quick. We got no fruit from it. Will I try it again – yes – because it has done well in the past.
Green Zebra
The next failure come from my sweetheart’s favorite. He loves Green Zebra. For years it grew well, then it didn’t for three years in a row. Because Russell loves it so much, I got seeds from a different company, same spindly plant that didn’t produce and died. If I keep trying it will be because he loves it so much and we can’t find it at the farmer’s market.
Lady Bug
Lady bug – really? This was the first year I grew it. It was supposed to be a super sweet, crack resistant red cherry. What was it? A tiny, dry, bland, meh tomato. Everyone who tried is scrunched up their face and said they never wanted to grow it.
Wine Jug
The last epic fail was one of those tomatoes that is watery and tasteless. I had high hopes for this one as it was bred by Brad Gates, of Wild Boar tomatoes and he grows several that have topped our tomato taste tests in the past. This fail was Wine Jug, named because of it’s shape. Everyone spit it out as gross – sorry Brad, I still love some of your other tomatoes!
That wraps up the 2025 tomato tasting summary. Hope you try some of these in your garden next year.
Companion Plant those Luscious Tomatoes
Get Debby’s top companion plants to grow along with your tomatoes in what she calls her “Tomato Guild”.
A group of plants that grow great together with your tomatoes for productively and beauty.








































































